SGT Auto Transport and Ship a Car Direct are both auto transport brokers that offer door-to-door car shipping and an online quote calculator. They differ most in BBB rating, price matching, and what backs you up if your car is damaged. As of October 14, 2026, Ship a Car Direct holds an A+ BBB rating and SGT Auto Transport holds a B.
Your vehicle is valuable, and safe handling matters. Car shipping can also be expensive, so comparing prices and services is the best way to get real value. Our guide on comparing car shipping quotes shows what to look for beyond the lowest number.
For a quick estimate, use our car shipping cost calculator, which needs no personal details, or request a full custom quote. Then compare either one with the quote you get from SGT Auto Transport.
How SGT Auto Transport and Ship a Car Direct Compare
| Business type | Auto transport broker | Auto transport broker |
| BBB rating | B, BBB accredited since 10/31/2023 | A+, BBB accredited since 2/19/2008 |
| Online quote | Instant online calculator, quote valid for 7 calendar days | Instant online calculator with no personal info, plus a full custom quote form |
| When payment is due | States it takes no deposit until a carrier is assigned | We don't charge our deposit until a carrier is assigned and confirmed |
| Insurance | The motor carrier's cargo insurance, with limits SGT states by trailer type | The carrier's insurance, which is always primary |
| Damage backup | None stated | Damage Free Guarantee: reimburses your deductible up to $500, or covers a repair of $500 or less |
| Door-to-door service | Yes | Yes |
SGT details were checked on SGT's website and BBB profile on October 14, 2026. BBB ratings and company processes change, so confirm both before you book.
Benefits of Ship a Car Direct
As an auto transport broker, Ship a Car Direct specializes in linking you with thoroughly vetted car transport companies. A key advantage of choosing us is our damage-free guarantee. The carrier's insurance pays first. In rare cases when a carrier refuses to pay, or when delays or disputes occur, the guarantee reimburses your deductible up to $500 or covers repairs of $500 or less directly.
Ship a Car Direct is also A+ rated by the BBB and, after almost 20 years in business, has tens of thousands of customer reviews across sites like Transport Reviews, Google, Trustpilot, and others.
Your vehicle will ship via a dedicated single carrier, reducing confusion and delivery issues. That carrier provides convenient door-to-door service. We don't charge our deposit until we assign and confirm a carrier, and our terms and conditions state when it is due.
About SGT Auto Transport
SGT Auto Transport is an auto transport broker based in Bohemia, New York, and its BBB profile lists it as in business since 2014. Its website describes door-to-door service to most destinations, with open and enclosed transport, an online quote calculator, quotes valid for 7 calendar days, and a promise to match a competing written quote.
SGT states that your vehicle is covered under the motor carrier's insurance policy, with cargo limits of $100,000 to $150,000 on open carriers and $250,000 to $3,000,000 on enclosed carriers.
SGT Auto Transport has a B rating with the BBB, checked October 14, 2026.
Common Questions About SGT Auto Transport and Ship a Car Direct
What is SGT Auto Transport?
SGT Auto Transport is a licensed auto transport broker in Bohemia, New York. According to its website, it arranges shipments with independent carriers and does not own trucks.
How does SGT Auto Transport work?
You enter your pickup and delivery locations, vehicle details, whether the car runs, the transport type, and your first available pickup date into SGT's online calculator, or you speak with an advisor. SGT's website says quotes are free and valid for 7 calendar days. After you book, SGT assigns a carrier, and the carrier contacts you a few hours before pickup.
SGT describes two payment options: a discounted price with a partial payment when a carrier is assigned and the balance paid to the driver at delivery, or a regular price paid in full when the booking is confirmed. We checked these details on October 14, 2026.
What are the benefits of using Ship a Car Direct over SGT Auto Transport to ship a car to another state?
Ship a Car Direct offers four advantages for interstate car shipping: one point of contact from pickup to delivery, a screened carrier network, an A+ BBB rating, and a Damage Free Guarantee. Our team monitors each shipment and stays in touch throughout. We vet every carrier for safety, insurance coverage, performance history, and customer feedback.
What is SGT Auto Transport’s BBB rating?
As of October 14, 2026, SGT Auto Transport has a B rating with the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and has been BBB accredited since October 31, 2023. BBB describes it as an automobile transport broker. Ratings change, so check the current BBB profile before you book.
How much does SGT Auto Transport cost?
SGT's prices come from its own online calculator, so we can't say what SGT will charge to ship your car. Its website says quotes are free and valid for 7 calendar days. You can use our Free Car Shipping Calculator to get a baseline estimate with no personal info. For a sense of typical pricing, check what state-to-state car shipping usually costs, then compare it with SGT's quote.
Is SGT Auto Transport or Ship a Car Direct better?
It depends on what matters most to you. SGT advertises a price-match guarantee on competing written quotes, which may suit shoppers who put price first. Ship a Car Direct may be a better fit if you want an A+ BBB rating as of October 14, 2026, and a Damage Free Guarantee as backup coverage. The carrier's insurance pays first, and the guarantee applies only if the carrier refuses to pay or there are delays or disputes.
If Montway Auto Transport is also on your shortlist, read our comparison of Montway Auto Transport and Ship a Car Direct.
Which auto transport company is most reliable?
The most reliable auto transport company has consistent, verifiable customer reviews and a strong BBB record, not the one holding the top spot on a comparison site. Many of those sites are pay-for-placement, meaning the company that pays the most gets the top spot, whether that's valid or not. It is better to read user review sites like Yelp, Google, and the BBB to see true experiences from previous customers. Our list of red flags in auto transport scams also shows how to check a company before you pay.
Choosing Between SGT Auto Transport and Ship a Car Direct
BBB standing, price matching, and damage protection are the three points that separate these two companies. SGT Auto Transport may suit you if a price-match guarantee matters most. We are confident Ship a Car Direct is the better fit if you want an A+ rated company and a Damage Free Guarantee as backup coverage, and we would like to show you. The carrier's insurance pays first, and the guarantee steps in only if the carrier refuses to pay or there are delays or disputes. Request a free car shipping quote today and see what we can offer.
